Series reading guide · updated 2026
Ettie Smith Amish Mysteries Books in Order
Every Ettie Smith Amish Mysteries book in publication order — 23 in total, spanning 2015–2020.
Publication Order of Ettie Smith Amish Mysteries Books
| # | Title | Year | Get it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Secrets Come Home | 2015 | Amazon US UK |
| 2 |  Amish Murder | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 3 |  Murder in the Amish Bakery | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 4 |  Amish Murder Too Close | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 5 |  Amish Quilt Shop Mystery | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 6 |  Amish Baby Mystery | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 7 |  Betrayed | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 8 |  Amish False Witness | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 9 |  Amish Barn Murders | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 10 |  Amish Christmas Mystery | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 11 |  Who Killed Uncle Alfie? | 2017 | Amazon US UK |
| 12 |  Lost: Amish Mystery | 2017 | Amazon US UK |
| 13 |  Amish Cover-Up | 2017 | Amazon US UK |
| 14 |  Amish Crossword Murder | 2017 | Amazon US UK |
| 15 |  Old Promises | 2017 | Amazon US UK |
| 16 |  Amish Mystery At Rose Cottage | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 17 |  Amish Mystery: Plain Secrets | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 18 |  Fear Thy Neighbor | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 19 |  Amish Winter Murder Mystery | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 20 |  Amish Scarecrow Murders | 2019 | Amazon US UK |
| 21 |  Threadly Secret | 2019 | Amazon US UK |
| 22 | Sugar and Spite | 2019 | Amazon US UK |
| 23 | A Puzzling Amish Murder | 2020 | Amazon US UK |
Every title by year All 23, oldest to newest
| # | Title | Year | Get it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Secrets Come Home | 2015 | Amazon US UK |
| 2 | Amish Murder | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 3 | Murder in the Amish Bakery | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 4 | Amish Murder Too Close | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 5 | Amish Quilt Shop Mystery | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 6 | Amish Baby Mystery | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 7 | Betrayed | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 8 | Amish False Witness | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 9 | Amish Barn Murders | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 10 | Amish Christmas Mystery | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 11 | Who Killed Uncle Alfie? | 2017 | Amazon US UK |
| 12 | Lost: Amish Mystery | 2017 | Amazon US UK |
| 13 | Amish Cover-Up | 2017 | Amazon US UK |
| 14 | Amish Crossword Murder | 2017 | Amazon US UK |
| 15 | Old Promises | 2017 | Amazon US UK |
| 16 | Amish Mystery At Rose Cottage | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 17 | Amish Mystery: Plain Secrets | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 18 | Fear Thy Neighbor | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 19 | Amish Winter Murder Mystery | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 20 | Amish Scarecrow Murders | 2019 | Amazon US UK |
| 21 | Threadly Secret | 2019 | Amazon US UK |
| 22 | Sugar and Spite | 2019 | Amazon US UK |
| 23 | A Puzzling Amish Murder | 2020 | Amazon US UK |
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.