Series reading guide · updated 2026
Amish Mysteries Books in Order
Every Amish Mysteries book in publication order — 9 in total, spanning 2012–2019.
Publication Order of Amish Mysteries Books
| # | Title | Year | Get it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Hearse and Buggy | 2012 | Amazon US UK |
| 2 |  Assaulted Pretzel | 2013 | Amazon US UK |
| 3 |  Shunned and Dangerous | 2014 | Amazon US UK |
| 4 |  Suspendered Sentence | 2015 | Amazon US UK |
| 5 | A Christmas Mourning | 2015 | Amazon US UK |
| 6 |  A Churn for the Worse | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 7 | Plain as Day | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 8 |  Just Plain Murder | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 9 |  A Killer Carol | 2019 | Amazon US UK |
Every title by year All 9, oldest to newest
| # | Title | Year | Get it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hearse and Buggy | 2012 | Amazon US UK |
| 2 | Assaulted Pretzel | 2013 | Amazon US UK |
| 3 | Shunned and Dangerous | 2014 | Amazon US UK |
| 4 | Suspendered Sentence | 2015 | Amazon US UK |
| 5 | A Christmas Mourning | 2015 | Amazon US UK |
| 6 | A Churn for the Worse | 2016 | Amazon US UK |
| 7 | Plain as Day | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 8 | Just Plain Murder | 2018 | Amazon US UK |
| 9 | A Killer Carol | 2019 | Amazon US UK |
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.